M
MoneyMath

1099 vs W2 Offer Comparison — Which Pays More?

Got two competing job offers — one W2, one 1099? See which is worth more after taxes, health insurance, 401(k) match, PTO, and all the benefits that only W2 employees get for free.

🟢 Updated April 2026👤 Reviewed by MoneyMath Editorial⚡ Runs in your browser · inputs never leave your device
W2 offer
$
$
$
$
$
1099 contract
$
$
Your tax situation
1099 wins by
$15,475.71
/yr after taxes + self-paid benefits
W2 offer
Gross compensation$118,000.00
+ PTO value$6,346.15
+ Benefits (health, 401k, other)$12,300.00
Take-home after tax$70,848.00
1099 offer
Gross billed$156,400.00
- Business expenses($6,000.00)
- Self-employment tax($21,250.84)
- Federal income tax($26,836.72)
- State income tax($6,988.73)
Take-home before self-paid benefits$95,323.71
- Self-paid health insurance (est.)($9,000.00)
Net take-home$86,323.71
Equivalent 1099 rate to match W2 take-home:

$76.59/hr at 40 hrs × 46 wks, after self-paid health of $9,000.00/yr.

Is 1099 actually worth more than W2?

Almost never at the same nominal rate. Converting $100K salary to $100K on 1099 is a pay cut of roughly 20-30% after you account for self-employment tax, lost benefits, and unbillable time. The break-even rate is usually 1.3-1.5× the equivalent W2 hourly rate.

Hidden costs of going 1099

  • Self-employment tax (15.3%). You pay both halves of Social Security + Medicare. Up to the $168,600 SS wage base (2024/2026 figure) then just 2.9% Medicare + 0.9% additional Medicare over $200K.
  • Health insurance. Employer-paid is worth $5K-$20K/yr. On 1099 you buy it on the ACA exchange (unsubsidized $400-$1,500/mo for single, more for family) or via a spouse's plan.
  • No 401(k) match. Employer matches average 3-5% of salary — $3K-$8K/yr of free money gone.
  • No PTO. Take 3 weeks off = 3 weeks of zero income. W2 you get paid.
  • No disability / life. Add $50-200/mo if you want coverage.
  • Unemployment insurance = zero. If the contract ends, no UI benefits.
  • Gap weeks. Between contracts, zero pay. Budget for 4-8 unpaid weeks a year.
  • Accounting + LLC admin. $500-2,000/yr for bookkeeper / CPA / LLC filing.

Hidden benefits of going 1099

  • Business deductions. Home office, computer, software, travel, mileage, continuing education. Lowers your taxable income.
  • QBI deduction (Section 199A). Up to 20% of qualified business income deductible against federal income tax. Phases out for specified service trades above the income thresholds.
  • SEP-IRA / Solo 401(k). Contribute up to $69,000/yr (2024/2026) vs $23,000 in a regular 401(k). Massive retirement savings vehicle for high earners.
  • Rate control. Raise your rate between contracts. Fire bad clients. Stack multiple at once.
  • Schedule flexibility. Some trade for lifestyle what they leave on the table in benefits.

The rate-conversion rule of thumb

A fast approximation: 1099 rate should be ~1.5x your equivalent W2 hourly to match total compensation after taxes + benefits + unbillable time. $100K W2 ≈ $50/hr equivalent → 1099 should clear $75/hr to match. This calculator gives you a more precise number based on your real inputs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I form an LLC or S-corp before going 1099?

LLC is low-friction — protects personal assets, costs $50-800 to form depending on state. S-corp election is worth running numbers on once net income exceeds ~$80K (see our LLC vs S-corp calculator) — can save $3K-$10K/yr in SE tax.

What health insurance do contractors use?

ACA marketplace (healthcare.gov) is the default. Subsidies phase out near $60-75K MAGI single. Spouse-of-W2 is cheapest if available. Health sharing ministries (Sedera, Christian HealthShare) are cheaper but not insurance and not ACA-compliant.

How much of my health insurance can I deduct?

100% of premiums via the Self-Employed Health Insurance (SEHI) deduction — but only up to the amount of your net self-employment income. Reduces taxable income, not SE tax.

Do I need to make quarterly estimated tax payments?

Yes. IRS wants ~90% of current year tax (or 100-110% of prior year) paid in four installments: April 15, June 15, Sept 15, Jan 15. See our Quarterly Tax Calculator. Miss them and you owe penalty + interest.

Can I deduct commuting to the client's office?

Usually no. Commuting from home to a regular work location is not deductible. Travel between clients, to a client out of town, or to a temporary assignment (under 1 year) usually is deductible.

What about the QBI deduction — do I qualify?

Depends on your field + income. Under the 2024/2026 thresholds (~$383K MFJ, ~$191K single) you get the full 20% regardless. Above that, "specified service trades" (consulting, law, accounting, health, etc.) get phased out.